Navigating Biflation: When Inflation and Deflation Coexist


Biflation is a unique economic phenomenon characterized by the simultaneous occurrence of inflation and deflation within an economy. while the term might seem contradictory, it actually reflects relative changes in prices among different economic goods and asset classes rather than a general rise or decline in all prices. This article explores the concept of biflation, its causes, and its implications for various sectors of the economy. we’ll also delve into examples of biflation in history and its relationship with monetary policy.

Biflation: navigating the paradoxical economic phenomenon

In the realm of economics, concepts such as inflation and deflation are well-known and often discussed. however, there exists a more complex and intriguing phenomenon called biflation. biflation is not a conventional term; rather, it represents an uneven response in the economy to changes in monetary policy. in this comprehensive guide, we’ll dissect the intricacies of biflation, its underlying causes, and the effects it has on various sectors of the economy.

Understanding biflation

Biflation, a term coined in 2003 by dr. f. osborne brown, a senior financial analyst for the phoenix investment group, emerges when central banks employ expansionary monetary policies to stimulate a stagnant economy. this unique economic condition arises because of the relative change in prices among different goods and asset classes, driven by alterations in the supply of money and credit in distinct markets.

Unlike traditional inflation and deflation, which refer to economy-wide changes in price levels, biflation is characterized by shifts in relative prices. it describes a specific type of cantillon effect—a concept introduced by the 18th-century economist richard cantillon. a cantillon effect refers to uneven changes in relative prices resulting from shifts in the money supply.

During a period of biflation, expansionary monetary policies inject money into the economy, leading to increased demand for commodity assets. this heightened demand causes prices of commodities like oil and building materials to rise. simultaneously, prices of debt-based assets, such as home mortgages and related securities, tend to decline, creating a scenario where inflation and deflation coexist within the same economy.

The cantillon effect

The cantillon effect sheds light on how money introduced into the economy does not uniformly boost demand for all assets. instead, certain assets experience increased favoritism, resulting in price surges in some economic sectors and price drops in others. these differential and sequential changes in prices across various markets can often blur the lines between inflation and deflation in the overall economy.

Biflation occurs when central banks attempt to counteract a recession and debt deflation by infusing money into the economy. paradoxically, the newly created money tends to be directed toward the purchase of commodities and related assets rather than combatting the ongoing deflationary trend in debt markets. as a result, biflation can lead to rising costs of living alongside falling employment rates, resembling the effects of stagflation.

Causes of biflation

Several factors contribute to the emergence of biflation in an economy. in a depressed economic environment, demand for essential raw materials, such as energy, clothing, and food, remains relatively high, as these are deemed indispensable purchases. consumers continue buying these items, even in the face of rising prices, leaving them with less disposable income for non-essential expenses.

On the other hand, leveraged assets like real estate often experience price decreases during economic stagnation and increased unemployment. in such conditions, people may hesitate to invest in costly non-essential items, even when low-interest rates make borrowing more affordable. the result is a pronounced disparity in price movements across different sectors of the economy, giving rise to biflation.

Examples of biflation

One of the most notable instances of biflation occurred in the aftermath of the great recession of 2007–2009. facing high unemployment rates and a struggling housing sector, the federal reserve implemented substantial monetary stimulus measures while pledging to maintain low-interest rates.

However, the impact of these measures was not uniform across the economy. instead of directing the new funds towards lending to distressed businesses, many banks and wall street institutions held the money as cash or invested it in speculative asset classes. consequently, while housing prices eventually recovered, they did so at a slower pace than liquid assets like stocks, which attracted investors due to improved corporate earnings driven by low-interest rates.

This divergence in asset performance led to a decline in housing prices in many regions, while prices for commodities like gasoline and gold witnessed an upswing. this scenario exemplifies biflation, where inflation and deflation simultaneously affect different economic sectors.

Globalization and biflation

Biflation has been exacerbated by globalization and the financialization of the world economy. following the great recession, assets that experienced strong demand and inflation were often those traded globally. rapidly industrializing countries such as india and china significantly drove up prices for many commodities, making essential raw materials more expensive for consumers in the western world.

As consumers faced financial hardships, their demand for items purchased on credit, such as homes and automobiles, decreased significantly. this contributed to a lack of demand for these non-essential items, further exacerbating the phenomenon of biflation.

Historical Instances of Biflation

Examining past instances of biflation provides valuable insights into how this economic phenomenon can manifest and its wide-ranging effects. here, we explore historical examples of biflation and the unique circumstances that gave rise to them.

The 1970s oil crisis: biflation’s precursor

Before the term “biflation” was coined, the 1970s oil crisis serves as a precursor to this phenomenon. during this period, the global economy experienced rising energy prices due to geopolitical tensions and supply disruptions in the oil market. while energy prices soared, many other sectors of the economy faced stagnation or even recession. this episode illustrates how a spike in commodity prices, particularly oil, can trigger a form of biflation.

The post-pandemic recovery: biflation in the 21st century

The covid-19 pandemic and its aftermath provide a

contemporary example of biflation. as central banks worldwide deployed extensive monetary stimulus to counteract the economic fallout of the pandemic, the effects were unevenly distributed. while asset prices, such as stocks and real estate, surged to record highs, sectors like hospitality and retail struggled. this divergence underscores the role of monetary policy in exacerbating price disparities and contributing to biflation.

Implications of Biflation on Investment Strategies

Understanding how biflation can impact investment strategies is crucial for investors looking to navigate the complexities of this economic phenomenon. here, we explore the implications of biflation on various asset classes and provide insights into investment approaches tailored to biflationary conditions.

Asset allocation in a biflationary environment

Investors facing biflation must carefully consider their asset allocation strategies. while traditional inflationary hedges like gold and real estate may protect against rising commodity prices, they might not safeguard against the declining value of debt-based assets. diversifying across asset classes and incorporating inflation-protected securities can help mitigate the risks associated with biflation.

Biflation and the stock market: identifying opportunities

The stock market often exhibits mixed reactions to biflation, with some sectors benefiting while others falter. identifying industries that thrive during biflation, such as commodities, can be an effective investment strategy. additionally, evaluating the financial health and adaptability of companies in the face of biflation can help investors make informed decisions in a biflationary environment.

The bottom line

In conclusion, biflation is a complex economic phenomenon characterized by the simultaneous occurrence of inflation and deflation in an economy. unlike traditional inflation and deflation, biflation reflects changes in relative prices among different economic goods and asset classes, driven by shifts in the supply of money and credit. understanding biflation is crucial for economists and policymakers, as it highlights the nuanced effects of monetary policy on various sectors of the economy.

Frequently asked questions

What is meant by biflation?

Biflation is a unique economic phenomenon where inflation and deflation occur simultaneously within an economy. Unlike traditional inflation and deflation, which involve general price changes, biflation refers to relative price changes among different economic goods and asset classes.

How does biflation differ from traditional inflation and deflation?

Biflation differs from traditional inflation and deflation in that it doesn’t result in a uniform rise or fall in all prices across the economy. Instead, it leads to a scenario where some prices, often commodity-linked assets, rise while others, like debt-based assets, fall.

What causes biflation?

Biflation typically arises when central banks implement expansionary monetary policies to stimulate an economy during a period of stagnation or recession. These policies can lead to increased demand for commodity assets, driving their prices up, while debt-based assets may decline in value.

Can you provide historical examples of biflation?

One notable historical example of biflation occurred in the aftermath of the Great Recession of 2007–2009. During this period, the Federal Reserve injected substantial monetary stimulus into the economy. While housing prices lagged, prices for commodities like gasoline and gold surged, illustrating the coexistence of inflation and deflation.

What are the implications of biflation on investment strategies?

Biflation can have significant implications for investors. Asset allocation becomes crucial, as traditional inflation hedges like gold may not protect against falling debt-based asset prices. Diversifying across asset classes and considering inflation-protected securities can help manage risks associated with biflation.

How does globalization contribute to biflation?

Globalization can exacerbate biflation by influencing the demand for commodities on a global scale. Rapidly industrializing countries, such as India and China, can drive up prices for essential raw materials, making them more expensive in Western economies. This, coupled with financialization, can intensify the phenomenon of biflation.

Is biflation a long-term economic condition?

Biflation is often a result of specific economic circumstances, such as central bank interventions during economic downturns. It may not be a long-term condition but rather a temporary response to these situations. Its duration depends on various economic factors and policies.

Key takeaways

  • Biflation is the simultaneous occurrence of inflation and deflation in an economy, characterized by relative changes in prices among different goods and asset classes.
  • It often arises when central banks implement expansionary monetary policies during economic stagnation.
  • Biflation involves a decline in prices for debt-based assets and a rise in prices for commodity-linked assets.
  • Globalization and financialization have contributed to the exacerbation of biflation in the world economy.
View article sources
  1. Biflation – definition and explanation – Economics Help
  2. Biflation is the new reality –
  3. Deflation How To Survive And Trive In The Coming Wa – Middle East Institute