Skip to content
SuperMoney logo
SuperMoney logo

Dividends vs. Capital Gains: Understanding Investor Preferences and Strategies

Last updated 02/18/2024 by

Abi Bus

Edited by

Fact checked by

The bird-in-hand theory examines investor preferences between dividends and capital gains, emphasizing the allure of certain dividend income over uncertain capital gains. This comprehensive exploration delves into the origins of the theory, its implications for investors, and the interplay between dividends and capital gains in investment strategies.

Exploring the bird-in-hand theory

The bird-in-hand theory, derived from the proverb “a bird in the hand is worth two in the bush,” posits that investors prefer the reliability of dividends over the uncertainty of potential capital gains. Myron Gordon and John Lintner introduced this concept as a counterpoint to the Modigliani-Miller dividend irrelevance theory, which suggests that investors are indifferent to the source of their returns—dividends or capital gains.

The role of dividends

Dividends represent a portion of a company’s earnings distributed to shareholders. They offer a predictable stream of income, making them particularly attractive to income-focused investors, such as retirees or those seeking steady cash flow from their investments. Dividend-paying stocks are often perceived as more stable and less volatile than non-dividend-paying stocks, appealing to risk-averse investors.

The allure of capital gains

Capital gains, on the other hand, arise from the appreciation in the value of an investment over time. Investors realize capital gains when they sell an asset for a higher price than they paid for it. While capital gains can potentially yield higher returns than dividends, they are inherently uncertain and subject to market volatility. Investors pursuing capital gains must accept greater risk in exchange for the possibility of higher rewards.

Comparing dividends and capital gains


One of the primary advantages of dividends is their reliability. Companies that consistently pay dividends demonstrate financial stability and a commitment to returning capital to shareholders. In contrast, capital gains are influenced by numerous factors, including market conditions, economic trends, and company performance, making them less predictable.


While dividends offer stability, they may also signal slower growth potential for a company. Companies that prioritize dividend payments may have fewer funds available for reinvestment in growth opportunities. Conversely, capital gains investing carries higher risk but also the potential for greater rewards, particularly in industries experiencing rapid expansion or technological innovation.

Tax considerations

From a tax perspective, dividends and capital gains are treated differently. Dividends are typically taxed as ordinary income, subject to the investor’s marginal tax rate. In contrast, capital gains are subject to capital gains tax, which may be lower than the tax rate on ordinary income, especially for long-term investments. Investors should consider their tax situation when determining the most advantageous investment strategy.
Here is a list of the benefits and the drawbacks to consider.
  • Dividend income provides certainty and stability.
  • Stocks with higher dividend yields may command higher market prices.
  • During market downturns, dividend income tends to be more reliable than capital gains.
  • Pure dividend investing may yield lower returns compared to capital gains investing over the long term.
  • Inflation may erode the purchasing power of dividend income during certain periods.

Frequently asked questions

Is the bird-in-hand theory applicable to all investors?

The bird-in-hand theory resonates more strongly with income-focused investors seeking steady cash flow from their investments. However, investors with a higher risk tolerance or those focused on long-term growth may prioritize capital gains over dividends.

How do companies decide whether to pay dividends?

Companies evaluate various factors when determining dividend payments, including their financial performance, cash flow, growth prospects, and capital allocation priorities. Management’s decision to pay dividends versus reinvesting profits in the business depends on these considerations and the company’s overall strategy.

Are there any drawbacks to relying solely on dividend income?

While dividend income provides stability, it may not keep pace with inflation during certain periods. Additionally, companies may reduce or suspend dividend payments during economic downturns or financial difficulties, impacting investors relying on dividend income for cash flow.

What factors should investors consider when choosing between dividends and capital gains?

Investors should assess their financial goals, risk tolerance, and investment time horizon when deciding between dividends and capital gains. Additionally, tax considerations, market conditions, and individual stock characteristics should be taken into account.

Can investors receive both dividends and capital gains from their investments?

Yes, investors can potentially benefit from both dividends and capital gains depending on their investment portfolio. Some stocks offer both dividends and the potential for capital appreciation, providing investors with a diversified income stream and the opportunity for long-term growth.

How can investors mitigate the risks associated with dividends and capital gains?

Diversification is key to mitigating risks associated with dividends and capital gains. By investing in a variety of assets across different sectors and industries, investors can spread risk and reduce the impact of adverse events on their portfolio. Additionally, staying informed about market trends and company fundamentals can help investors make informed decisions and navigate changing market conditions.

Key takeaways

  • The bird-in-hand theory suggests that investors prefer the reliability of dividends over the uncertainty of potential capital gains.
  • Dividends offer a predictable stream of income, appealing to risk-averse investors, while capital gains carry higher risk but also the potential for greater rewards.
  • Considerations such as reliability, risk, and tax implications influence investors’ preferences between dividends and capital gains.

Share this post:

You might also like