Skip to content
SuperMoney logo
SuperMoney logo

Enhanced Indexing: Understanding Strategies, Examples, and Risks

Last updated 02/14/2024 by

Silas Bamigbola

Edited by

Fact checked by

Enhanced indexing is a hybrid portfolio management strategy that aims to amplify returns compared to strict indexing while minimizing tracking error. This article explores how enhanced indexing works, its various strategies, advantages, disadvantages, and its role in investment portfolios.

Compare Investment Advisors

Compare the services, fees, and features of the leading investment advisors. Find the best firm for your portfolio.
Compare Investment Advisors

Introduction to enhanced indexing

Enhanced indexing is a portfolio management approach that seeks to exceed the returns of an underlying portfolio or index while minimizing tracking error. It blends elements of both active and passive management, offering investors an alternative to traditional indexing.

How enhanced indexing works

Enhanced indexing combines features of both active and passive management. It resembles passive management by closely tracking commercially available indexes, resulting in low turnover and reduced fees compared to actively managed portfolios. However, enhanced index managers have the flexibility to make strategic deviations from the underlying index to optimize returns, minimize costs, and enhance tax efficiency.

Types of enhanced indexing strategies

Enhanced indexing encompasses various strategies tailored to meet specific investment objectives:

Enhanced cash

This strategy involves using futures contracts to replicate the index and investing in fixed income securities. Managers aim to achieve higher yields on fixed income securities than those priced into the futures contracts, thus enhancing returns.

Trading enhancements

Managers may employ intelligent trading algorithms to create value through trading activities, such as purchasing illiquid positions at a discount or executing patient selling strategies.

Index construction enhancements

Enhanced indexing strategies may utilize proprietary dynamic indexes instead of traditional static indexes, providing more flexibility and responsiveness to market changes.

Exclusion rules

Enhanced indexing allows for additional filters to exclude undesirable companies based on criteria like excessive debt or bankruptcy, enhancing portfolio quality.

Tax-managed strategies

Tax-managed index funds prioritize tax efficiency by minimizing taxable events, which is particularly beneficial for portfolios held outside of tax-advantaged accounts.

Other strategies

Investors can implement various strategies, such as short-selling underperforming stocks from an index and reallocating funds to high-performing securities, to enhance portfolio performance over time.

Pros and cons of enhanced index funds

Weigh the risks and benefits
Here is a list of the benefits and drawbacks to consider.
  • Potential for higher returns compared to traditional indexing
  • Flexibility to optimize portfolio performance
  • Opportunity to minimize tax liabilities
  • Manager risk due to active management
  • Higher expense ratios and turnover rates compared to index funds
  • Limited track record compared to traditional investment instruments

Examples of enhanced indexing strategies

Illustrative examples of enhanced indexing strategies showcase the versatility and effectiveness of this approach:

Sector rotation

Sector rotation is a dynamic investment strategy that involves adjusting portfolio allocations based on the performance outlook of specific sectors within the economy. The premise of sector rotation is to capitalize on economic cycles and sector-specific trends to enhance portfolio returns.
Investors employing sector rotation strategies analyze various sectors, such as technology, healthcare, consumer discretionary, and energy, to identify those poised for growth or facing headwinds. During economic expansions, sectors like technology and consumer discretionary may outperform, while defensive sectors like utilities and consumer staples may lag.

Factor-based investing

Factor-based investing involves selecting securities based on specific factors such as value, growth, size, and momentum. Enhanced index funds employing factor-based strategies may tilt towards stocks exhibiting characteristics associated with higher returns, such as low price-to-earnings ratios or strong price momentum.

Enhanced indexing in practice

Real-world applications of enhanced indexing highlight its adaptability and efficacy in various market conditions:

Institutional portfolios

Institutional investors, such as pension funds and endowments, often incorporate enhanced indexing strategies to enhance portfolio performance while managing risk. By combining passive indexing with active management techniques, institutions aim to achieve superior risk-adjusted returns and fulfill long-term financial obligations.

Retail investment products

Retail investors can access enhanced indexing through a range of investment products, including exchange-traded funds (ETFs) and mutual funds. These products offer retail investors exposure to diversified portfolios that seek to outperform traditional indexes, providing an alternative to actively managed funds with potentially lower fees and greater tax efficiency.


Enhanced indexing represents a dynamic approach to portfolio management, combining elements of both active and passive strategies. By allowing managers to make strategic deviations from underlying indexes, enhanced index funds seek to optimize returns while minimizing tracking error.
Throughout this exploration, we’ve delved into the workings of enhanced indexing, examining various strategies, advantages, and disadvantages. From enhanced cash strategies to tax-managed approaches, investors have a range of options to consider when incorporating enhanced indexing into their investment portfolios.

Frequently asked questions

What are the main differences between enhanced indexing and traditional indexing?

Enhanced indexing incorporates elements of both active and passive management, allowing for strategic deviations from the underlying index to potentially optimize returns. Traditional indexing typically involves passive management, with the goal of closely tracking the performance of a specific index.

How do enhanced index funds compare to actively managed funds?

Enhanced index funds blend active and passive management strategies, offering a middle ground between traditional index funds and actively managed funds. While enhanced index funds have lower expense ratios compared to actively managed funds, they still carry higher fees and turnover rates than traditional index funds.

What are the key risks associated with enhanced index funds?

Enhanced index funds carry additional risks, including manager risk due to active management strategies. Poor decisions by fund managers can negatively impact returns. Additionally, enhanced index funds may experience higher turnover rates, leading to increased transaction costs and potential tax implications for investors.

How can investors determine if enhanced index funds are suitable for their investment portfolio?

Investors should consider their investment goals, risk tolerance, and investment time horizon when evaluating the suitability of enhanced index funds. Those seeking potentially higher returns with moderate risk tolerance and a long-term investment horizon may find enhanced index funds appealing.

What factors should investors consider when selecting an enhanced index fund?

When selecting an enhanced index fund, investors should consider factors such as expense ratios, historical performance, turnover rates, and the fund’s investment strategy. It’s essential to thoroughly research and understand the fund’s objectives and underlying holdings before investing.

Can enhanced index funds be tax-efficient investment options?

Enhanced index funds may offer tax-efficient benefits compared to actively managed funds, particularly if they prioritize tax-managed strategies. By minimizing taxable events within the fund, investors can potentially reduce their tax liabilities, especially for investments held outside of tax-advantaged accounts.

Are there any regulatory considerations or oversight for enhanced index funds?

Enhanced index funds are subject to regulatory oversight by relevant financial authorities, ensuring compliance with securities regulations and investor protection measures. Investors can review regulatory filings, fund prospectuses, and performance reports to gain insights into a fund’s compliance and adherence to regulatory standards.

Key takeaways

  • Enhanced indexing blends active and passive management to optimize portfolio returns.
  • Various strategies, such as enhanced cash and tax-managed strategies, contribute to enhanced index fund performance.
  • Investors should weigh the benefits of higher returns against the potential risks and fees associated with enhanced index funds.
  • Regulatory oversight ensures compliance and investor protection within the enhanced indexing landscape.
  • Choosing the right enhanced index fund requires thorough research and consideration of factors such as expense ratios, historical performance, and investment strategy.
  • While enhanced index funds offer potential advantages, investors should align their investment objectives and risk tolerance before integrating them into their portfolios.

SuperMoney may receive compensation from some or all of the companies featured, and the order of results are influenced by advertising bids, with exception for mortgage and home lending related products. Learn more

Loading results ...

Share this post:

You might also like