Flotation Costs: Explained, Calculation, and Practical Examples
SB
Summary:
Flotation costs, incurred when a company issues new securities, impact the cost of new equity and affect capital-raising decisions. Understanding how to calculate these costs is crucial for sound financial management. This article delves into the concept of flotation costs, their calculation, implications, and more.
Understanding flotation costs
Flotation costs are an essential consideration for publicly-traded companies planning to issue new securities. These costs encompass various expenses such as underwriting fees, legal fees, and registration fees. They play a pivotal role in determining the amount of capital a company can raise through a new securities offering.
Flotation costs are not isolated; they tie into factors like expected return on equity, dividend payments, and the percentage of earnings a business plans to retain. Understanding these interconnected elements is crucial to calculating a company’s cost of new equity.
The formula for calculating float in new equity
The flotation cost of new equity can be calculated using the dividend growth rate. The formula for this is:
Dividend growth rate = (D1 / P) + g
Where:
- D1 = the dividend in the next period
- P = the issue price of one share of stock
- g = the dividend growth rate
Understanding this formula is essential for estimating the flotation cost of new equity accurately.
Real-life examples of flotation costs
Understanding flotation costs is easier when you see how they apply to actual situations. Let’s explore some real-life examples:
1. Initial Public Offering (IPO)
When a company decides to go public through an Initial Public Offering (IPO), it typically incurs substantial flotation costs. These costs may include underwriting fees, legal fees, accounting fees, and costs related to listing on stock exchanges. For instance, a tech startup planning to raise capital by offering its shares to the public will face these expenses. The total flotation cost will impact the share price and the amount of capital the company can raise.
2. Debt vs. equity issuance
Companies often face a choice between raising capital through debt (bonds) or equity (common stock). Let’s consider a manufacturing company that needs to raise $50 million. If it chooses to issue bonds, the flotation costs may be lower compared to issuing common stock. This decision can significantly affect the company’s overall cost of capital and the financial structure of the business.
3. Seasoned Equity Offering (SEO)
A Seasoned Equity Offering is when a company that’s already publicly traded issues additional shares of common stock. This scenario involves flotation costs as well. For instance, a well-established retail corporation aiming to expand its operations may opt for an SEO to raise funds. The flotation costs, in this case, can impact the decision to use existing equity or issue new shares.
4. Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs)
Even small and medium-sized enterprises may encounter flotation costs when they decide to raise capital. Let’s consider a family-owned restaurant business planning to open new locations. If they choose to issue shares, they’ll need to account for the associated costs. This decision will influence the ownership structure of the business and its financial strategy.
5. Market conditions and flotation costs
Market conditions play a vital role in determining flotation costs. For example, during a period of low interest rates and favorable investor sentiment, flotation costs may be relatively lower. On the contrary, in a volatile market, companies might face higher costs when issuing new securities. The choice of the timing for capital raising decisions can significantly impact the financial health of the company.
These real-life examples demonstrate how flotation costs are not just theoretical but have a tangible impact on a company’s financial strategy and its ability to raise capital.
Pros and cons of flotation costs
Companies raise capital through debt and equity. Flotation costs come into play when a company issues new equity, like newly issued common stock. These costs include expenses such as investment banking and legal fees, accounting and audit fees, and fees paid to stock exchanges to list the company’s shares. The difference between the cost of existing equity and the cost of new equity represents the flotation cost.
The flotation cost is expressed as a percentage of the issue price and is included in the price of new shares. To determine the optimal funding mix between new equity and debt, companies often use a weighted cost of capital (WACC) calculation.
Example of a flotation cost calculation
Consider Company A, which needs $100 million in capital and plans to raise this through $10 per share common stock. Investment bankers receive 7% of the funds raised. Company A pays out $1 in dividends per share next year, with an expected 10% increase in dividends the following year.
Using these variables, the cost of new equity is calculated as follows:
($1 / ($10 * (1-7%)) + 10%) = 20.7%
If we assume no flotation cost, the cost of existing equity is calculated as:
($1 / ($10 * (1-0%)) + 10%) = 20.0%
The difference between the cost of new equity and the cost of existing equity represents the flotation cost, which is (20.7% – 20.0%) = 0.7%. In other words, the flotation costs increased the cost of the new equity issuance by 0.7%.
Limitations of using flotation costs
Some analysts argue that incorporating flotation costs into the company’s cost of equity implies that these costs are an ongoing expense, which can overstate the firm’s cost of capital indefinitely. In reality, a company pays flotation costs once when issuing new equity. To address this, some analysts adjust the company’s cash flows to account for flotation costs.
Factors influencing flotation costs
Flotation costs aren’t static; they can vary significantly depending on several factors. Understanding these factors is crucial for assessing the potential impact on capital-raising decisions. Key factors include:
1. Size of the offering
The size of the securities offering plays a pivotal role in determining flotation costs. Larger offerings tend to have higher costs due to increased underwriting, legal, and registration expenses.
2. Type of security
The type of security being issued also influences flotation costs. For instance, issuing common stock typically incurs higher costs than issuing bonds or preferred stock.
3. Market conditions
The prevailing market conditions, including interest rates and investor sentiment, can impact flotation costs. In favorable conditions, costs may be lower.
Practical application of flotation costs
To grasp the significance of flotation costs, let’s consider a practical scenario:
Company B’s capital expansion
Company B is a tech startup looking to raise $20 million in capital for expansion. They are considering issuing common stock at $20 per share. Investment bankers charge a 5% fee on funds raised. The company pays out $1 per share in dividends and expects a 12% increase in dividends the following year.
Using these details, Company B’s flotation cost is calculated as:
($1 / ($20 * (1-5%)) + 12%) = 16.5%
Had there been no flotation costs, the cost of existing equity would be:
($1 / ($20 * (1-0%)) + 12%) = 12%
The difference between the two represents the flotation cost, which in this case is (16.5% – 12%) = 4.5%. This demonstrates how flotation costs can significantly impact a company’s cost of equity and capital-raising decisions.
Conclusion
Flotation costs are a crucial aspect of financial management for publicly-traded companies. Understanding these costs, their calculation, and the various factors affecting them is essential for making sound financial decisions. By considering these costs, companies can make informed choices about their capital-raising strategies.
Frequently asked questions
What are some common examples of flotation costs?
Common examples of flotation costs include underwriting fees, legal fees, registration fees, and costs associated with listing shares on stock exchanges. These are incurred when a company issues new securities.
How do fluctuations in market conditions affect flotation costs?
Market conditions, such as interest rates and investor sentiment, can impact flotation costs. In favorable conditions, costs may be lower, while adverse conditions may result in higher costs. It’s important to consider market dynamics when assessing the potential impact of flotation costs.
Can flotation costs be avoided when raising capital?
Flotation costs are inherent to raising capital through new securities, particularly when issuing common stock. While they can’t be entirely avoided, companies can make strategic decisions to minimize these costs. For example, they may choose to issue bonds or preferred stock instead, which often have lower flotation costs.
Why is accurate calculation of the cost of new equity important for businesses?
Accurate calculation of the cost of new equity is crucial because it affects a company’s cost of capital and, subsequently, its ability to raise funds. A precise understanding of the cost of new equity helps businesses make informed financial decisions and choose the most cost-effective capital-raising methods.
How do flotation costs impact a company’s financial performance in the long run?
Flotation costs are often considered a one-time expense. However, some analysts argue that including them in the cost of equity can overstate a company’s cost of capital indefinitely. It’s important to recognize that these costs are incurred when issuing new equity and may have a lasting impact on financial performance if not accounted for properly.
Key takeaways
- Flotation costs are incurred by companies issuing new securities and include expenses like underwriting and legal fees.
- Accurate calculation of the cost of new equity is vital for informed financial decisions.
- The difference between the cost of existing equity and new equity represents the flotation cost.
- Flotation costs are a one-time expense that some analysts adjust for in cash flow calculations.
Share this post: