Skip to content
SuperMoney logo
SuperMoney logo

Accidental High Yielders: Understanding, Identifying, and Investing

Last updated 03/17/2024 by

Silas Bamigbola

Edited by

Fact checked by

Summary:
Accidental high-yielders are companies that pay unusually high dividend yields due to a decline in their stock prices, despite no change in their dividend policy. Understanding these stocks, their risks, and potential rewards is crucial for investors seeking to maximize their returns while managing their risks effectively.

Compare Investment Advisors

Compare the services, fees, and features of the leading investment advisors. Find the best firm for your portfolio.
Compare Investment Advisors

What are accidental high yielders?

An accidental high yielder is a term used to describe companies whose dividend yields become abnormally high due to a decline in their stock prices, without any corresponding change in their dividend policies. This phenomenon typically occurs during bear markets or periods of economic uncertainty when stock prices fall sharply.

Key characteristics of accidental high yielders

Accidental high yielders share several key characteristics:
  • They maintain a consistent dividend payment despite a decline in their stock price.
  • They often emerge during bear markets or periods of economic downturn.
  • Investors can potentially benefit from both high dividend yields and capital appreciation if they buy these stocks at low prices.
  • However, investing in accidental high yielders solely based on their dividend yields can be risky, as continued price declines may outweigh the benefits of dividend payments.

Understanding dividend yields

Dividend yield is a crucial metric for evaluating the attractiveness of a stock’s dividend payments. It is calculated by dividing the annual dividend per share by the current market price per share. A higher dividend yield indicates that the company is paying out a larger proportion of its earnings in dividends relative to its share price.

Examples of accidental high yielders

One real-world example of an accidental high yielder is BP (BP), a multinational oil and gas company. In 2019, BP paid dividends totaling $2.46 per share, resulting in a dividend yield of approximately 6.5% based on its stock price at the time.
However, in 2020, amidst the 2020 crisis and a collapse in oil prices, BP’s stock price plummeted, causing its dividend yield to spike to 11.4%. Despite doubling its dividend yield, BP did not change its dividend policy, making it an accidental high yielder during this period.
Several companies have experienced periods of becoming accidental high yielders due to various market conditions. Here are a few examples:
AT and T (T): In 2020, AT and T’s stock price declined significantly amidst market volatility, causing its dividend yield to spike. Despite maintaining its dividend payments, AT and T became an accidental high yielder during this period.
General electric (GE): During the 2008 financial crisis, General Electric’s stock price plummeted, resulting in a high dividend yield relative to its stock price. The company maintained its dividend payments, making it an accidental high yielder until its stock price recovered.
Ford motor company (F): In recent years, Ford has experienced fluctuations in its stock price due to various economic factors. Despite maintaining its dividend policy, Ford has periodically become an accidental high yielder during periods of market uncertainty.

Pros and cons of investing in accidental high yielders

Weigh the risks and benefits
Here is a list of the benefits and drawbacks of investing in accidental high yielders:
Pros
  • Potential for high dividend yields.
  • Opportunity for capital appreciation if stock prices rebound.
  • Attractive investment during bear markets.
Cons
  • Risk of continued price declines.
  • Possibility of dividend cuts if financial conditions worsen.
  • May be perceived as value traps if stock prices do not recover.

Factors influencing accidental high yielders

Several factors contribute to a company becoming an accidental high yielder, including:
Market conditions: Economic downturns, bear markets, or industry-specific challenges can lead to significant declines in stock prices, resulting in higher dividend yields.
Dividend policy: Companies that maintain consistent dividend payments despite stock price declines are more likely to become accidental high yielders.
Investor sentiment: Market perceptions of a company’s financial health and future prospects can influence its stock price and dividend yield.

Strategies for identifying accidental high yielders

Investors can employ various strategies to identify potential accidental high yielders and capitalize on their investment opportunities:
Screening for High Dividend Yields: Utilizing stock screening tools to identify companies with unusually high dividend yields relative to their stock prices can help investors pinpoint potential accidental high yielders.
Analyzing Dividend Payment History: Examining a company’s dividend payment history can provide insights into its dividend policy and whether it has maintained consistent payments despite fluctuations in its stock price.
Assessing Fundamental Indicators: Conducting a thorough analysis of a company’s financial health, including its earnings growth, debt levels, and cash flow, can help investors gauge the sustainability of its dividend payments.

Conclusion

Accidental high yielders can present attractive investment opportunities for income-focused investors, especially during bear markets. However, it’s essential to conduct thorough research and consider both the potential rewards and risks before investing in these stocks. While high dividend yields may be appealing, investors should also assess the company’s financial health, dividend sustainability, and long-term growth prospects.

Frequently asked questions

What causes a company to become an accidental high yielder?

A company becomes an accidental high yielder when its stock price declines significantly without a corresponding change in its dividend policy. This typically occurs during bear markets or periods of economic uncertainty.

Are accidental high yielders a good investment?

Investing in accidental high yielders can potentially provide attractive dividend yields and opportunities for capital appreciation. However, investors should carefully assess the risks, including the possibility of continued price declines and dividend cuts.

How can investors identify accidental high yielders?

Investors can identify accidental high yielders by looking for companies with high dividend yields relative to their stock prices, especially during periods of market downturns. Additionally, analyzing the company’s dividend history and financial health can help determine if it is likely to maintain its dividend payments.

What are the risks associated with investing in accidental high yielders?

While accidental high yielders may offer attractive dividend yields, they also come with risks. These risks include the potential for continued price declines, dividend cuts, and the perception of being value traps if stock prices do not recover.

How do market conditions influence accidental high yielders?

Market conditions, such as economic downturns or industry-specific challenges, can significantly impact accidental high yielders. During bear markets or periods of economic uncertainty, stock prices may decline sharply, leading to higher dividend yields for these companies.

What is the role of dividend policy in determining accidental high yielders?

The dividend policy of a company plays a crucial role in determining whether it becomes an accidental high yielder. Companies that maintain consistent dividend payments despite declines in their stock prices are more likely to be classified as accidental high yielders.

Can accidental high yielders be sustainable investments?

While accidental high yielders may present short-term opportunities for high dividend yields, their long-term sustainability depends on various factors, including the company’s financial health, dividend policy, and ability to navigate market conditions. Investors should carefully evaluate these factors before considering them as long-term investments.

Key takeaways

  • Accidental high yielders are companies that pay unusually high dividend yields due to a decline in their stock prices, despite no change in their dividend policy.
  • Investing in accidental high yielders can present opportunities for high dividend yields and potential capital appreciation, especially during bear markets.
  • However, investors should carefully assess the risks, including the possibility of continued price declines and dividend cuts.
  • Thorough research and analysis of a company’s financial health, dividend policy, and market conditions are essential before investing in accidental high yielders.
  • Diversification is key to managing risk in a portfolio that includes accidental high yielders, as it can help mitigate the impact of adverse events affecting individual stocks.

SuperMoney may receive compensation from some or all of the companies featured, and the order of results are influenced by advertising bids, with exception for mortgage and home lending related products. Learn more

Loading results ...

Share this post:

You might also like