Negative Convexity: Definition, Examples, and Implications
SB
Summary:
Negative convexity occurs when a bond’s price falls as interest rates decline, leading to a concave yield curve. This phenomenon is particularly relevant in the world of fixed-income securities and has significant implications for investors. In this article, we’ll delve into the definition, implications, and methods for calculating negative convexity, providing you with a comprehensive understanding of this concept.
Negative convexity: a comprehensive guide
When it comes to understanding fixed-income securities and bonds, the concept of convexity is crucial. Negative convexity is a particularly fascinating aspect that warrants a closer look.
What is negative convexity?
Negative convexity exists when the shape of a bond’s yield curve is concave. A bond’s convexity is the rate of change of its duration, and it is measured as the second derivative of the bond’s price with respect to its yield. Most mortgage bonds are negatively convex, and callable bonds usually exhibit negative convexity at lower yields.
Understanding the significance
A bond’s duration refers to the degree to which a bond’s price is impacted by the rise and fall of interest rates. Convexity demonstrates how the duration of a bond changes as the interest rate changes. Typically, when interest rates decrease, a bond’s price increases. However, for bonds that have negative convexity, prices decrease as interest rates fall.
For example, consider a callable bond. As interest rates fall, the incentive for the issuer to call the bond at par increases; therefore, its price will not rise as quickly as the price of a non-callable bond. In fact, the price of a callable bond might actually drop as the likelihood that the bond will be called increases. This is why the shape of a callable bond’s curve of price with respect to yield is concave or negatively convex.
Calculating negative convexity
To better understand the impact of negative convexity and how it’s measured, investors, analysts, and traders use a concept called convexity.
Convexity calculation example
The exact formula for convexity can be complex, but an approximation can be calculated using the following simplified formula:
Convexity approximation = (P(+) + P(-) – 2 x P(0)) / (2 x P(0) x dy^2)
Where:
– P(+) = bond price when the interest rate is decreased
– P(-) = bond price when the interest rate is increased
– P(0) = bond price
– dy = change in interest rate in decimal form
– P(-) = bond price when the interest rate is increased
– P(0) = bond price
– dy = change in interest rate in decimal form
For example, assume a bond is currently priced at $1,000. If interest rates are decreased by 1%, the bond’s new price is $1,035. If interest rates are increased by 1%, the bond’s new price is $970. The approximate convexity would be:
Convexity approximation = ($1,035 + $970 – 2 x $1,000) / (2 x $1,000 x 0.01^2) = $5 / $0.2 = 25
The convexity adjustment
When applying this to estimate a bond’s price using duration, a convexity adjustment must be used. The formula for the convexity adjustment is:
Convexity adjustment = convexity x 100 x (dy)^2
In this example, the convexity adjustment would be:
Convexity adjustment = 25 x 100 x (0.01)^2 = 0.25
Finally, using duration and convexity to obtain an estimate of a bond’s price for a given change in interest rates, an investor can use the following formula:
Bond price change = duration x yield change + convexity adjustment
Pros and cons of negative convexity
Additional examples of negative convexity
Understanding negative convexity is crucial, and additional examples can provide further clarity:
Example 1: Mortgage-backed securities
Mortgage-backed securities (MBS) are prime examples of bonds with negative convexity. When interest rates drop, homeowners tend to refinance their mortgages to take advantage of lower rates. As a result, MBS investors may face early repayments, leading to the loss of anticipated interest income. This illustrates how MBS exhibit negative convexity, as the expected cash flows decrease as rates fall.
Example 2: Callable corporate bonds
Callable corporate bonds can be subject to negative convexity as well. When interest rates decline, the issuer may choose to call the bond, refinancing it at a lower rate. Investors holding these bonds could face a situation where the bond is redeemed early, and they miss out on future interest payments, leading to potential capital losses.
Strategies for managing negative convexity
1. Diversification
One strategy for managing the risks associated with negative convexity is diversification. By holding a mix of different bond types in a portfolio, you can potentially offset losses in one area with gains in another. Diversification can help mitigate the impact of interest rate fluctuations.
2. Interest rate hedging
Another approach is to use interest rate derivatives, such as interest rate swaps or options, to hedge against the potential losses from negative convexity. These instruments can help protect a portfolio from adverse interest rate movements, though they come with their own complexities and risks.
The real-world impact of negative convexity
Mortgage market impact
The concept of negative convexity has substantial real-world implications in the mortgage market. Mortgage lenders need to manage the risk of early loan repayments by homeowners seeking better rates, which affects their profitability. As a result, interest rate trends play a significant role in the mortgage industry’s decision-making processes.
Investor decision-making
Understanding negative convexity is critical for investors when deciding which bonds to include in their portfolios. The presence of negative convexity can influence investment choices, risk tolerance, and the desired balance between potential yield and interest rate risk.
Conclusion
Negative convexity is a nuanced concept that plays a significant role in the world of fixed-income securities. Investors and portfolio managers must grasp its implications and intricacies to make informed decisions. It can be a valuable tool for managing interest rate risk, but it also comes with its own set of challenges. By understanding negative convexity and its impact on bond prices, you can navigate the complex landscape of fixed-income investments with more confidence.
Frequently asked questions
What are the main drivers of negative convexity in bonds?
Negative convexity in bonds is primarily driven by features that affect the relationship between bond prices and changes in interest rates. Callable bonds, for instance, tend to exhibit negative convexity because as interest rates fall, the issuer’s incentive to call the bond at par increases, leading to a concave price-yield curve. Mortgage-backed securities (MBS) are also known for their negative convexity, as homeowners tend to refinance when rates drop, resulting in early repayments and reduced cash flows.
How does negative convexity impact investment decisions?
Negative convexity can significantly impact investment decisions, especially for fixed-income investors. It introduces a risk that bond prices may not rise as expected when interest rates fall, potentially leading to capital losses. Investors must consider their risk tolerance and yield objectives when choosing bonds with negative convexity. Understanding this concept helps in making informed investment choices and managing the balance between yield and interest rate risk.
What strategies can be employed to mitigate the impact of negative convexity?
To mitigate the impact of negative convexity, diversification is a common strategy. By including various types of bonds in a portfolio, investors can offset potential losses in one area with gains in others. Additionally, interest rate hedging using derivatives like interest rate swaps or options can help protect against adverse rate movements, although it comes with its own complexities and risks.
How do I calculate convexity and the convexity adjustment for a bond?
Calculating convexity and the convexity adjustment for a bond involves mathematical formulas. Convexity can be approximated using the formula: Convexity approximation = (P(+) + P(-) – 2 x P(0)) / (2 x P(0) x dy^2), where P(+) is the bond price when interest rates decrease, P(-) is the bond price when rates increase, P(0) is the bond’s current price, and dy is the change in interest rates in decimal form. The convexity adjustment is then calculated as: Convexity adjustment = convexity x 100 x (dy)^2.
Why is understanding negative convexity important for investors and portfolio managers?
Understanding negative convexity is essential for investors and portfolio managers as it influences investment decisions and risk management. It helps in selecting bonds that align with investment goals and risk tolerance. Being aware of the impact of negative convexity on bond prices allows for more informed decision-making and the effective management of interest rate risk in a fixed-income portfolio.
Key takeaways
- Negative convexity leads to a concave relationship between a bond’s price and its yield.
- Understanding convexity is vital for fixed-income investors and portfolio managers.
- Convexity calculations help in refining interest rate risk management.
- Callable bonds are often associated with negative convexity.
Share this post: