Skip to content
SuperMoney logo
SuperMoney logo

Underwithholding: Definition, How It Works, and Examples

Last updated 03/29/2024 by

Bamigbola Paul

Edited by

Fact checked by

Underwithholding occurs when an individual fails to withhold a sufficient amount of taxes from their income throughout the year, leading to potential penalties and a higher tax bill at the end of the year. This article delves into the concept of underwithholding, its causes, consequences, and how it differs from overwithholding.

Understanding underwithholding and its implications

Underwithholding is a tax-related term that denotes a situation where an individual hasn’t withheld enough taxes from their earnings during the year to meet their tax obligations. This often leads to unforeseen tax liabilities and potential penalties when filing taxes. Let’s delve deeper into the mechanics and consequences of underwithholding:

How underwithholding occurs

Underwithholding typically occurs due to various reasons:
  • Inaccurate W-4 information: When individuals fill out their W-4 forms incorrectly or fail to update them to reflect changes in their financial situations, they may end up withholding less tax than required.
  • Additional income streams: People with multiple income sources, such as side gigs or investments, might not withhold enough tax from each source, leading to underpayment.
  • Unanticipated tax deductions: If taxpayers anticipate significant deductions on their tax returns and adjust their withholdings accordingly, they may inadvertently underwithhold if their estimates are inaccurate.

Strategies to avoid underwithholding

It’s essential to take proactive measures to avoid underwithholding:

Regularly review W-4 forms

Individuals should review and update their W-4 forms regularly, especially when experiencing significant life changes such as marriage, divorce, or changes in employment status.

Utilize tax withholding estimators

Online tax withholding calculators provided by the IRS can help individuals determine the appropriate amount of tax to withhold from their paychecks based on their income, deductions, and filing status.

Consider quarterly estimated tax payments

For those with additional income streams or self-employment income, making quarterly estimated tax payments can help prevent underwithholding and avoid penalties at the end of the tax year.
Pros and cons of underwithholding
Here is a list of the benefits and drawbacks associated with underwithholding:
  • Allows individuals to retain more of their income throughout the year, potentially for investment or savings purposes.
  • Provides flexibility in managing cash flow, especially for individuals with variable income.
  • May result in tax refunds for individuals who overwithhold, providing a financial boost.
  • Can lead to unexpected tax bills and penalties if individuals underwithhold and fail to meet their tax obligations.
  • May result in reduced financial flexibility and missed investment opportunities for individuals who overwithhold.
  • Requires careful tax planning and monitoring to avoid potential pitfalls and consequences.

The pitfalls of overwithholding

While some individuals deliberately underwithhold to invest the withheld funds and potentially earn a profit, others may opt to overwithhold to ensure a tax refund at the end of the year. However, overwithholding comes with its own set of drawbacks:

Lost opportunity costs

By overwithholding, individuals essentially provide the government with an interest-free loan, missing out on potential investment or savings opportunities.

Reduced cash flow

Overwithholding can lead to reduced cash flow throughout the year, as individuals have less take-home pay due to higher tax withholdings.

Lack of financial flexibility

Receiving a large tax refund may seem like a windfall, but it often indicates that individuals have been overpaying taxes throughout the year, limiting their financial flexibility and ability to address immediate needs or emergencies.

Examples of underwithholding

Let’s explore some scenarios where underwithholding may occur:

Example 1: freelance income

A freelance graphic designer fails to adjust their tax withholdings to account for their freelance income, resulting in underpayment of taxes throughout the year. When filing their tax return, they realize they owe a significant amount in taxes, including penalties for underpayment.

Example 2: investment gains

An individual invests in stocks and earns substantial capital gains throughout the year. However, they neglect to increase their tax withholdings to cover the additional tax liability generated by these gains. As a result, they face a hefty tax bill and penalties for underwithholding.

The importance of proper tax planning

Proper tax planning is essential to avoid underwithholding and its associated consequences. Let’s delve into the significance of effective tax planning:

Maximizing deductions and credits

By strategically maximizing deductions and credits, individuals can reduce their taxable income and mitigate the risk of underwithholding. This involves leveraging available deductions such as mortgage interest, charitable contributions, and education expenses.

Utilizing retirement accounts

Contributing to retirement accounts such as 401(k)s and IRAs not only helps individuals save for retirement but also reduces their taxable income. By taking advantage of these tax-advantaged accounts, individuals can lower their tax liability and avoid underwithholding.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between underwithholding and overwithholding?

Underwithholding occurs when individuals fail to withhold sufficient taxes from their income throughout the year, resulting in potential penalties and a higher tax bill at the end of the year. On the other hand, overwithholding involves withholding more taxes than necessary, leading to a tax refund but potentially missing out on investment opportunities.

How can I determine if I am underwithholding?

You can determine if you are underwithholding by reviewing your tax withholdings throughout the year and comparing them to your estimated tax liability. If you consistently owe taxes when filing your tax return or face penalties for underpayment, you may be underwithholding.

What are the penalties for underwithholding?

The penalties for underwithholding include fines imposed by the IRS for failing to pay sufficient taxes throughout the year. These penalties can increase the overall tax burden and diminish any potential tax refunds.

Can I adjust my tax withholdings during the year?

Yes, you can adjust your tax withholdings during the year by submitting a new Form W-4 to your employer. This form allows you to update your withholding allowances and ensure that you are withholding the correct amount of taxes from your paycheck.

Are there any exceptions to underwithholding penalties?

Yes, there are exceptions to underwithholding penalties. If you meet certain criteria, such as paying at least 90% of your current year’s taxes or 100% of your previous year’s taxes (whichever is smaller), you may be exempt from penalties.

What steps can I take to avoid underwithholding?

To avoid underwithholding, you can regularly review and update your W-4 form, utilize tax withholding estimators provided by the IRS, and consider making quarterly estimated tax payments if you have additional income streams or self-employment income.

Key takeaways

  • Underwithholding occurs when individuals fail to withhold sufficient taxes from their earnings throughout the year.
  • Consequences of underwithholding include penalties, unexpected tax bills, and financial strain.
  • To avoid underwithholding, individuals should regularly review their W-4 forms, use tax withholding estimators, and consider quarterly estimated tax payments.
  • Overwithholding, while ensuring a tax refund, can lead to lost opportunity costs and reduced financial flexibility.

SuperMoney may receive compensation from some or all of the companies featured, and the order of results are influenced by advertising bids, with exception for mortgage and home lending related products. Learn more

Loading results ...

Share this post:

You might also like