Skip to content
SuperMoney logo
SuperMoney logo

Payment Option ARMs: Understanding, Risks, and Examples

Last updated 03/15/2024 by

Daniel Dikio

Edited by

Fact checked by

Payment Option ARMs, or Adjustable-Rate Mortgages, offer borrowers a range of payment choices each month, including fully amortizing, interest-only, and minimum payments. These mortgages provide flexibility but also carry risks such as payment shock and negative amortization, where the loan balance increases over time. Understanding the terms and implications of Payment Option ARMs is essential for borrowers considering this type of mortgage.

Compare Home Loans

Compare rates from multiple vetted lenders. Discover your lowest eligible rate.
Compare Rates

The ins and outs of payment option ARMs

A Payment Option Adjustable-Rate Mortgage (ARM) is a type of mortgage that offers borrowers various payment options each month. This flexibility distinguishes it from traditional fixed-rate or adjustable-rate mortgages, allowing borrowers to select from different payment structures based on their financial situation and goals.

Understanding payment option ARM terms

Payment option ARMs provide borrowers with several payment choices, including:
  • A 30 or 40-year fully amortizing payment
  • A 15-year fully amortizing payment
  • An interest-only payment
  • A minimum payment or a payment greater than the minimum
The minimum payment option is initially calculated based on a temporary start interest rate, usually set below the fully indexed rate. During this introductory period, the minimum payment is fully amortizing. However, once the temporary start rate expires, the minimum payment option persists, potentially leading to negative amortization if payments are less than the interest-only amount.

Risks associated with payment option ARMs

While payment option ARMs offer flexibility, they also carry significant risks that borrowers should be aware of:
  • Interest rate fluctuations: Payment option ARMs are susceptible to fluctuations in interest rates, which can lead to unpredictable changes in monthly payments.
  • Payment shock: Borrowers may experience payment shock when their monthly payments increase significantly, especially after the initial low-interest period ends.
  • Negative amortization: Making minimum payments below the interest-only amount can result in negative amortization, where the loan balance increases over time.
  • Recasting risks: If the negative amortization limit is reached, the mortgage may recast, leading to higher monthly payments and potentially financial strain for borrowers.
  • Financial instability: Payment option ARMs may not be suitable for borrowers with uncertain or unstable financial situations, as they require careful financial planning and management.
  • Long-term debt accumulation: Some borrowers may underestimate the long-term implications of payment option ARMs, leading to increased debt accumulation and potential financial hardship in the future.
It’s essential for borrowers to carefully assess their financial circumstances and risk tolerance before opting for a payment option ARM. Seeking advice from financial experts and understanding the terms of the mortgage can help mitigate potential risks and ensure informed decision-making.

The drawbacks of payment option ARMs

Payment option ARMs gained popularity before the mortgage crisis but later faced criticism for several reasons:
  • Some borrowers opted for smaller payments without fully understanding the long-term implications, leading to growing mortgage debt.
  • Lenders sometimes extended payment option ARMs to borrowers who could not afford traditional mortgages, contributing to default rates during the financial crisis.
Despite these drawbacks, payment option ARMs can benefit certain borrowers:
  • Real estate investors may find payment option ARMs appealing for short-term property investments, particularly if they plan to renovate and sell quickly.

Examples of payment option ARM scenarios

Consider the following scenarios to understand how payment option ARMs work in real-life situations:
  • Scenario 1: A borrower opts for the minimum payment option during the initial period when the interest rate is low. However, as the interest rate increases over time, the minimum payment may not cover the accruing interest, leading to negative amortization.
  • Scenario 2: Another borrower chooses the interest-only payment option to lower monthly payments temporarily. While this may provide short-term relief, it can result in a higher principal balance over time.
  • Scenario 3: An investor utilizes a payment option ARM to purchase a property with the intention of renovating and selling it within a few years. The flexibility of payment options allows the investor to manage cash flow during the renovation process.

Managing risks with payment option ARMs

To mitigate the risks associated with payment option ARMs, borrowers should consider the following strategies:
  • Regular reviews: Regularly review the terms of the mortgage and monitor changes in interest rates to anticipate potential payment adjustments.
  • Financial planning: Develop a comprehensive financial plan that accounts for potential increases in monthly payments and negative amortization.
  • Refinancing options: Explore refinancing options if the terms of the payment option ARM no longer align with your financial goals or if more stable mortgage products become available.


Payment option ARMs offer borrowers flexibility in choosing their monthly payment options, allowing for various structures based on individual financial needs. However, they come with inherent risks, including payment shock and negative amortization.
It’s crucial for borrowers to thoroughly understand the terms and implications of payment option ARMs before committing to such a mortgage. While they may benefit certain borrowers, especially real estate investors, others may find traditional mortgage options more suitable for their financial goals.
By carefully evaluating the risks and benefits, and considering alternatives, borrowers can make informed decisions about whether a payment option ARM is the right choice for their specific circumstances.

Frequently asked questions

What is the initial start interest rate of a payment option ARM?

The initial start interest rate of a payment option ARM is typically lower than the fully indexed rate. It is used to calculate the minimum payment during the introductory period.

Can I change my payment option during the life of the loan?

Yes, most payment option ARMs allow borrowers to change their payment option, subject to certain terms and conditions outlined in the loan agreement.

How often can my monthly payment change with a payment option ARM?

The frequency of payment adjustments varies depending on the terms of the loan agreement. Some payment option ARMs may adjust monthly, while others adjust annually or at predetermined intervals.

What is negative amortization, and how does it impact my loan balance?

Negative amortization occurs when the minimum payment made by the borrower is insufficient to cover the accruing interest. As a result, the unpaid interest is added to the principal balance, leading to an increase in the loan amount over time.

Are payment option ARMs suitable for first-time homebuyers?

Payment option ARMs may not be suitable for all first-time homebuyers, as they carry inherent risks such as payment shock and negative amortization. It is important for borrowers to fully understand the terms and potential risks before choosing this type of mortgage.

Can I refinance my payment option ARM if I encounter financial difficulties?

Refinancing options may be available for borrowers experiencing financial difficulties with their payment option ARMs. However, eligibility for refinancing depends on various factors, including creditworthiness and equity in the property.

What should I consider before choosing a payment option ARM?

Before choosing a payment option ARM, borrowers should carefully evaluate their financial situation, long-term goals, and risk tolerance. It is advisable to consult with a financial advisor or mortgage specialist to assess the suitability of this type of mortgage.

Key takeaways

  • Payment option ARMs provide borrowers with flexibility in choosing their monthly payments.
  • Risks associated with payment option ARMs include payment shock and negative amortization.
  • Real estate investors may find payment option ARMs useful for short-term property investments.

SuperMoney may receive compensation from some or all of the companies featured, and the order of results are influenced by advertising bids, with exception for mortgage and home lending related products. Learn more

Loading results ...

You might also like