Skip to content
SuperMoney logo
SuperMoney logo

IRS Warns Thousands Could Face Jail Time Over Tax Refund Scams!

Last updated 05/16/2024 by

SuperMoney Team

Edited by

Summary:
The IRS has issued a warning to taxpayers about potential jail time if they filed fraudulent tax returns. Misleading advice has led many to make false claims for credits such as the Fuel Tax Credit, Sick and Family Leave Credit, and household employment taxes, putting them at risk of being scam victims.
The IRS recently alerted thousands of taxpayers about the risk of criminal prosecution due to fraudulent tax filings. Misleading advice has caused numerous individuals to falsely claim credits such as the Fuel Tax Credit, Sick and Family Leave Credit, and household employment taxes. This article examines the details of these scams, the penalties involved, and how to avoid becoming a victim.

Compare Tax Preparation Services

Compare multiple vetted providers. Discover your best option.
Compare Options

IRS warning: Understanding the risks

If the IRS releases a warning about criminal prosecution, it’s usually a good idea to pay attention. In 2023 (FY23), the IRS Criminal Investigation (CI) initiated more than 2,676 criminal investigations, identified over $37.1 billion from tax and financial crimes, and obtained an 88.4% conviction rate on cases accepted for prosecution.
The IRS has highlighted several tax credits that are often misused due to misleading advice. These include the Fuel Tax Credit, the Sick and Family Leave Credit, and household employment taxes. Taxpayers need to be vigilant about the information they receive, especially from social media or unverified sources. Misleading advice can lead to incorrect claims, resulting in significant legal and financial consequences.

Fuel Tax Credit

The Fuel Tax Credit is intended for businesses and farms that use fuel for off-highway purposes. However, some taxpayers have been wrongly advised to claim this credit, leading to false claims. This credit is highly specialized and is not available to most individuals.
For example, legitimate claims might involve farming equipment or machinery used in construction or logging activities. The credit does not apply to fuel used for personal vehicles or commuting. Claiming this credit improperly can trigger audits and severe penalties.
The Fuel Tax Credit is only available for specific off-highway uses such as farming or other business-related activities. Individuals claiming it for personal use are committing fraud.

Sick and Family Leave Credit

The Sick and Family Leave Credit was designed to help employers cover the cost of providing paid sick and family leave to employees. Misguided taxpayers have been led to believe they can claim this credit personally, resulting in incorrect filings.
This credit is strictly for employers who paid sick and family leave wages to their employees, particularly during the COVID-19 pandemic. It was available for the years 2020 and 2021, aimed at supporting businesses that offered paid leave. Incorrectly claiming this credit for personal use or outside the specified period is fraudulent.
The Sick and Family Leave Credit is only applicable to employers who provide paid leave to their employees, not to individuals claiming personal leave.

Household employment taxes

Household employment taxes apply to those who employ household workers, such as nannies or housekeepers. Misleading advice has prompted some taxpayers to falsely claim these taxes, thinking it will benefit them financially.
Some taxpayers have gone as far as inventing fictional household employees and filing Schedule H (Form 1040) to claim refunds based on wages that were never paid. This fraudulent activity not only leads to penalties but also risks criminal prosecution.
Legitimate claims involve actual employment relationships with household workers where the employer is responsible for withholding and paying social security, Medicare, and federal unemployment taxes. Claiming these taxes without proper employment records is illegal.

The consequences of fraudulent claims

Filing false tax returns can result in severe penalties, including:
  • Criminal prosecution: Tax fraud can lead to jail time if the IRS determines there was intentional wrongdoing.
  • Financial penalties: Taxpayers may face significant fines and be required to pay back the improperly claimed amounts with interest.
  • Credit damage: Fraudulent claims can negatively impact a taxpayer’s credit score, making it harder to obtain loans or other financial products.
In addition to these penalties, the IRS may impose a penalty of up to $5,000 for filing frivolous returns. Fraudulent claims can trigger audits, causing further stress and financial strain. Taxpayers should ensure their claims are accurate and supported by proper documentation to avoid these consequences.

Avoiding scams: Tips and advice

To avoid falling victim to tax scams, consider the following tips:
  • Verify information: Always cross-check advice from unofficial sources with reliable information from the IRS or a certified tax professional.
  • Understand eligibility: Make sure you fully understand the eligibility criteria for any tax credits or deductions you plan to claim.
  • Seek professional help: When in doubt, consult a certified tax professional to ensure your filings are accurate and compliant with IRS regulations.
Additionally, be cautious of advice that promises unusually large refunds or seems too good to be true. Always ensure that your tax preparer signs your return, as unsigned returns may indicate fraudulent activity.

SuperMoney may receive compensation from some or all of the companies featured, and the order of results are influenced by advertising bids, with exception for mortgage and home lending related products. Learn more

Loading results ...

IRS urges vigilance and proper filing

The IRS issued a consumer alert on May 14, 2024, due to ongoing concerns about tax scams and inaccurate social media advice leading to inflated refund claims. Taxpayers have been warned not to fall for scams centered around the Fuel Tax Credit, Sick and Family Leave Credit, and household employment taxes. Thousands of dubious claims have delayed refunds and required taxpayers to provide legitimate documentation to support their claims.
To address these issues, the IRS has frozen refunds for returns suspected of including fraudulent claims. Taxpayers who receive letters from the IRS should follow the instructions provided, which may include verifying their identity, providing additional documentation, or filing an amended return.
Taxpayers who filed these claims mistakenly need to follow advice on letters from the IRS, consider filing an amended return, or talk to a trusted tax professional.

Common themes in fraudulent claims

The IRS has identified three common themes among bad refund claims involving legitimate tax provisions but limited to specialized situations:

Fuel Tax Credit

Designed for off-highway business and farming use, this credit requires a business purpose and qualifying activities like running a farm. Most taxpayers do not qualify. Claims related to personal vehicle use or non-business activities are considered fraudulent. Taxpayers should consult the IRS guidelines or a tax professional to determine eligibility before filing.

Credits for Sick Leave and Family Leave

Available for self-employed individuals for 2020 and 2021 during the pandemic, this credit is not available for 2023 tax returns. The IRS has seen repeated instances of taxpayers incorrectly using Form 7202 to claim credits based on employee income. Proper claims must reflect paid leave provided to employees during the specified period, and misuse of this form can lead to serious consequences.

Household employment taxes

Some taxpayers invent fictional household employees and file Schedule H (Form 1040) to claim a refund based on false wages. Legitimate claims must involve actual employees with proper documentation and adherence to tax withholding requirements. Fraudulent claims in this category can result in severe penalties, including criminal prosecution.

Potential consequences and steps to resolve issues

Given the questionable nature of many claims, the IRS has frozen refunds for these taxpayers. Taxpayers need to follow specific steps to resolve these issues, such as verifying their identity, amending their tax returns, and providing legitimate documentation.
Taxpayers receiving IRS letters should carefully read and follow the provided instructions. This may include visiting the IRS website tool “Should I file an amended return?” to determine if an amendment is necessary. Providing accurate and complete information promptly can help resolve issues and potentially reduce penalties.

Dealing with substantial tax debt

Taxpayers with substantial tax debt should not ignore their obligations. The IRS offers various options for resolving tax debt, including installment agreements and offers in compromise. Seeking professional help from a certified tax professional or tax attorney can help manage and negotiate tax debt effectively.

SuperMoney may receive compensation from some or all of the companies featured, and the order of results are influenced by advertising bids, with exception for mortgage and home lending related products. Learn more

Loading results ...

Ignoring tax debt can lead to further penalties and legal action. It is crucial to address these issues promptly and work with the IRS to find a manageable solution. Tax professionals can provide valuable assistance in negotiating terms and ensuring compliance with IRS regulations.

Frequently asked questions

What should I do if I suspect I’ve made a false claim?

If you suspect you’ve made a false claim, contact the IRS immediately. Correcting the error voluntarily can mitigate some penalties. The IRS may be more lenient with taxpayers who proactively address their mistakes.

How can I tell if tax advice is misleading?

Check the credibility of the source. Reliable sources include the IRS website and certified tax professionals. Be wary of advice that promises unusually large refunds or seems too good to be true. Always verify information with official IRS resources or seek a second opinion from a trusted tax advisor.

Can the IRS really send me to jail for a false claim?

Yes, if the IRS determines that you intentionally filed a fraudulent claim, you could face criminal charges and potential jail time. Deliberate fraud is taken very seriously, and the IRS has the authority to prosecute offenders to the full extent of the law.

What is the IRS doing to prevent these scams?

The IRS is actively educating taxpayers about these scams through public warnings and outreach. They also investigate and prosecute those involved in fraudulent tax activities. The IRS’s efforts include identifying common scam themes, freezing suspicious refunds, and issuing penalties to deter fraudulent behavior.

Key takeaways

  • The IRS warns taxpayers about the risk of jail time for filing fraudulent returns.
  • Misleading advice has led to false claims for the Fuel Tax Credit, Sick and Family Leave Credit, and household employment taxes.
  • Penalties for fraudulent claims include criminal prosecution, financial penalties, and credit damage.
  • Verify tax advice with reliable sources and consult a certified tax professional if in doubt.
  • Taxpayers with substantial tax debt should seek professional help to manage and resolve their obligations.

SuperMoney may receive compensation from some or all of the companies featured, and the order of results are influenced by advertising bids, with exception for mortgage and home lending related products. Learn more

Loading results ...

Share this post:

You might also like