TaxSlayer vs eFile 2026 Comparison: Pricing, State Fees & Which Fits Your Return
Last updated 09/11/2025 by
Andrew Latham
Edited by
Andrew Latham
Summary:
Hunting for a low-cost DIY filer? TaxSlayer keeps prices lean with a speedy online workflow. eFile competes with ultra-affordable bundles for federal + state. The tradeoff: TaxSlayer’s broader tiers vs. eFile’s rock-bottom bundles for simple returns.
Compare Tax Preparation Services
Compare multiple vetted providers. Discover your best option.
Face-Off: TaxSlayer vs eFile Comparison
Here’s how they stack up on key pricing and features:
| Feature | TaxSlayer | eFile |
|---|---|---|
| Federal Basic Price | $0 | $0 |
| Federal Standard Price | $24.95 | $19.49 |
| Federal Premium Price | $44.95 | $34.49 |
| Federal Basic + State Price | $0 | $21 |
| State Return Price | $39.95 | $21 |
| State Return Availability | $39.95 | $21 |
| Filing Options | File Online | File Online |
| Software Offerings | Web Browser-Based | Web Browser-Based |
| Tax Preparation Types | Personal | Personal |
| Tax Prep Differentiators | Low-cost tiers; speedy DIY workflow | Ultra-low-cost federal + state bundles |
| SuperMoney User Score | mostly recommended | strongly recommended |
Who Should Choose TaxSlayer?
TaxSlayer is built for budget-minded DIY filers who want a quick, transparent online experience.
- Budget Tiers: Competitive prices across editions.
- DIY Workflow: Streamlined online filing for personal returns.
- Transparent Fees: Predictable pricing and minimal upsells.
- Online-Only: No in-person offices; support is lean.
Who Should Choose eFile?
eFile focuses on ultra-affordable online filing, especially for simple personal returns.
- Rock-Bottom Bundles: Federal + state packages priced to undercut rivals.
- Straightforward DIY: Simple web-based process.
- Transparent Pricing: Pay-as-you-go without hidden add-ons.
- Web-Only: No mobile app or in-person support.
Interface & Workflow
TaxSlayer prioritizes speed for experienced DIY filers. eFile keeps it bare-bones and affordable—great for simple scenarios.
Help & Assistance Channels
TaxSlayer offers lean online help resources. eFile similarly focuses on self-serve support without live or in-person help.
Refund Delivery Choices
Both support direct deposit for refunds; neither emphasizes refund advance products.
Key Differences (Updated 2026)
- Federal Filing Price: TaxSlayer starts at $0; eFile starts at $0.
- State Returns: TaxSlayer charges $39.95; eFile charges $21.
- Filing Options: Both are online-only DIY platforms—no in-person offices.
- Software: TaxSlayer offers broader tiers; eFile leans into ultra-cheap bundles.
- User Ratings: TaxSlayer’s score: mostly recommended; eFile’s score: strongly recommended.
Which Fits Your Filing Style?
- Choose TaxSlayer if: You want budget tiers and a slightly more developed DIY experience.
- Choose eFile if: Your return is simple and you want the lowest possible federal + state bundle.
Customer Reviews & Reputation
SuperMoney reviews highlight TaxSlayer’s value and speed with leaner support. eFile is praised for low pricing, but limited features and support are common tradeoffs.
- TaxSlayer Reviews: Value-focused; quick DIY experience.
- eFile Reviews: Ultra-affordable bundles; minimal support.
At-a-Glance Comparison: Support, Refund, Ease of Use
| Category | TaxSlayer | eFile |
|---|---|---|
| Support Options | Online help & resources | Online help center; limited support |
| Refund Options | Direct deposit | Direct deposit |
| Ease of Use | Lean, fast DIY | Basic web-based process |
| Best For | Budget DIY filers | Simple returns needing the lowest price |
| Customer Reviews | SuperMoney User Score: mostly recommended | SuperMoney User Score: strongly recommended |
Pricing Transparency
TaxSlayer keeps costs competitive with clear tiers. eFile undercuts on bundles but stays minimal on features and support.
What’s Next
Dig deeper into full reviews:
- TaxSlayer Review — Why budget-minded DIY filers choose it.
- eFile Review — How ultra-low-cost bundles can save you on simple returns.
Explore Other Tax Software Matchups
- TaxSlayer vs TurboTax — Budget DIY vs premium guidance.
- FreeTaxUSA vs TaxSlayer — Low-cost rivals head-to-head.
- Cash App Taxes vs TaxSlayer — Free filing vs budget tiers.
- FreeTaxUSA vs eFile — Free federal vs low-cost bundles.
- eFile vs Jackson Hewitt — Online DIY vs in-person service.
Don’t decide blind. Check every major provider on our tax preparation services hub.
Key Takeaways
- Federal Pricing: TaxSlayer starts at $0; eFile starts at $0.
- State Returns: TaxSlayer costs $39.95; eFile costs $21.
- Filing Options: Both are web-only DIY platforms without office networks.
- User Ratings: TaxSlayer: mostly recommended; eFile: strongly recommended.
FAQ
Is TaxSlayer cheaper than eFile?
Both are budget options; final cost depends on your edition and state needs—eFile’s bundles can be the lowest for simple returns.
Do either offer in-person help?
No. Both are online DIY platforms without office networks.
Which is better for a simple return?
eFile often wins on ultra-low bundle pricing; TaxSlayer offers more tier flexibility.
Which should I pick if I want more guidance?
Consider H&R Block or Jackson Hewitt for in-person help; these two focus on DIY.
Andrew is the Content Director for SuperMoney, a Certified Financial Planner®, and a Certified Personal Finance Counselor. He loves to geek out on financial data and translate it into actionable insights everyone can understand. His work is often cited by major publications and institutions, such as Forbes, U.S. News, Fox Business, SFGate, Realtor, Deloitte, and Business Insider.
Share this post:
Add
as a preferred source on GoogleTable of Contents