TurboTax vs. eFile: Which Tax Software Should You Choose?
Last updated 08/26/2025 by
Ante MazalinEdited by
Andrew LathamSummary:
TurboTax and eFile are both online tax preparation platforms but serve slightly different audiences. TurboTax is known for its step-by-step guidance and broad support, while eFile focuses on offering an affordable, straightforward filing experience. Choosing between them comes down to whether you prioritize hands-on guidance or low-cost simplicity.
Compare Tax Preparation Services
Compare multiple vetted providers. Discover your best option.
Quick Comparison: TurboTax vs. eFile
Here’s how TurboTax and eFile compare on core features:
| Feature | TurboTax | eFile |
|---|---|---|
| Federal Basic Price | $0 | $0 |
| Federal Standard Price | $79 | $19.49 |
| Federal Premium Price | $159 | $34.49 |
| Federal Self-Employed Price | Starting at $89 | |
| Federal Basic + State Price | $78 | $21 |
| State Return Price | $64 | $21 |
| State Return Availability | $0 - $64 | $21 |
| Filing Options | Mobile App, File Online | File Online |
| Software Offerings | Web Browser-Based, Desktop Software, Mobile App | Desktop Software |
| Tax Preparation Types | Business, Personal | Business, Personal |
| Tax Prep Differentiators | Import Return From Competitor, Automatic W2 Import, Access To Prior Year Returns, Automatic Error Detection, Tax Deduction Finder, Audit Support, Brokerage Investment Data Import | Automatic Error Detection,Tax Deduction Finder, Audit Support,IRS Free File |
| SuperMoney User Score | strongly recommended | strongly recommended |
About TurboTax
TurboTax is one of the most popular tax software platforms in the U.S., recognized for its guided experience and wide range of packages. It offers:
- Free Edition: Best for simple tax returns (Form 1040 only).
- Deluxe: Designed for maximizing deductions and credits.
- Premium: Ideal for investors, property owners, and more complex situations.
- Self-Employed: Tailored for freelancers and small business owners, with Schedule C support.
Users can also upgrade to Live Assisted or Full Service to get real-time help from tax professionals.
About eFile
eFile focuses on making tax filing quick, simple, and affordable. It provides an easy-to-use online interface and flat, low-cost pricing across its tiers. Key offerings include:
- Free Edition: Simple federal returns with optional state filing.
- Deluxe & Premium Options: Designed for filers who need itemized deductions or more support.
- Self-Employed: Support for gig workers and small business returns.
eFile appeals to cost-conscious taxpayers who want to file quickly without paying premium prices.
Key Differences
While both TurboTax and eFile help taxpayers prepare and file federal and state returns, they differ in cost, features, and support. Here are some of the most important differences to consider:
- Federal Basic Price: TurboTax starts at $0, while eFile begins at $0.
- Federal Premium Price: TurboTax charges $159, compared to eFile at $34.49.
- Self-Employed Filers: TurboTax’s self-employed package costs Starting at $89, while eFile’s comparable plan is .
- State Returns: State filing fees differ, with TurboTax at $64 and eFile at $21.
- Software Options: TurboTax offers web, desktop, and mobile app filing, while eFile provides a streamlined browser-based platform.
- Tax Prep Differentiators: TurboTax includes advanced features like deduction finders, W-2 import, and live CPA help. eFile emphasizes affordability and straightforward filing tools.
- SuperMoney User Score: TurboTax holds a rating of strongly recommended, while eFile is rated strongly recommended by SuperMoney users.
What’s Next
Still deciding between TurboTax and eFile? Review the full details, pricing, and user experiences to find the best fit for your tax filing needs.
- TurboTax Review — A comprehensive platform offering guided tax filing, premium support options, and robust deduction tools for all tax situations.
- eFile Review — A budget-friendly alternative with simple filing tools, ideal for confident DIY filers who want affordability and efficiency.
Explore Other Tax Software Comparisons
- Jackson Hewitt vs. H&R Block — Compare two of the largest tax preparation services offering online and in-person filing options.
- TurboTax vs. Jackson Hewitt — See how TurboTax’s guided software compares with Jackson Hewitt’s nationwide in-person network.
- TaxAct vs. TurboTax — Discover how TaxAct’s affordability stacks up against TurboTax’s extensive features and support.
- TurboTax vs. FreeTaxUSA — Learn whether a free-focused option like FreeTaxUSA is enough compared to TurboTax’s premium guidance.
- TurboTax vs. H&R Block — Explore the similarities and differences between two of the most popular tax filing platforms.
- TaxSlayer vs. TurboTax — Find out how TaxSlayer’s lower pricing compares with TurboTax’s premium features and support.
- FreeTaxUSA vs TaxSlayer — Compare two budget-friendly tax prep platforms to see which offers the better value.
Key Takeaways
- TurboTax offers a highly guided experience with robust support options, but at a higher price point.
- eFile provides a simple and affordable platform, best suited for confident DIY filers who don’t need extensive hand-holding.
- Both platforms support federal and state returns, but TurboTax has more premium features such as live CPA help and advanced deduction tools.
- Choosing between them depends on whether you value affordability and simplicity (eFile) or comprehensive guidance and extra features (TurboTax).
FAQ
Is TurboTax or eFile better for beginners?
TurboTax is generally better for beginners because it offers a step-by-step process, built-in guidance, and access to live tax professionals. eFile is simpler but requires more tax knowledge from the filer.
Which is cheaper: TurboTax or eFile?
eFile is usually the more affordable option, offering lower-cost filing packages. TurboTax tends to cost more but provides additional features, guidance, and support options.
Do both TurboTax and eFile support state tax returns?
Yes, both platforms allow you to file federal and state tax returns. However, the pricing for state returns may differ between the two services.
Can I access my past tax returns with TurboTax and eFile?
Yes, both platforms provide access to prior year tax returns, but TurboTax typically makes it easier to import past filings and information directly into the current year’s return.
Do TurboTax and eFile offer audit support?
Both provide some form of audit support, though TurboTax offers more comprehensive audit defense and assistance options, often available at an additional cost.
Share this post:
Table of Contents